Judging Criteria

Central Coast Writers Contest – Judging Criteria

The objective of each judge’s evaluation is to determine one overall score from 0 to 50 for each entry (50 being the best possible score).

The following criteria are to be used in evaluating each entry:

SHORT FICTION and FLASH FICTION

Use of the Theme                                                      10 Points Possible

Originality and creativity in interpretation and incorporation of the theme is demonstrated.

Plot and Story                                                            10 Points Possible

The plot is plausible and complete within the limits of the words allowed.  The story is original and compelling.  The story arc is logical and powerful.

Use of Language                                                        10 Points Possible

Proper grammar is employed, strong quality of writing is demonstrated, language is mined for maximum expression, use of slang or cursing is not distracting, repeated words are minimized, word choices are creative and effective, and figurative language (metaphor and simile) are fresh and unique.

Emotional Impact                                                      10 Points Possible

The story evokes emotion and allows for suspension of disbelief.

Narrative Voice and Content                                   10 Points Possible

The narrative voice is distinct and engaging and the point of view is effective and consistent.  Any shifts in point of view are clear and intentional.  The characters are well developed in the narrative and are unique and interesting.   The dialogue is convincing and fresh and reveals the character(s).  The speakers are identifiable.  The description of the setting invokes an identifiable sense of place and the descriptions are vivid.

SCREENWRITING

Use of the Theme                                                     10 Points Possible

Originality and creativity in interpretation and incorporation of the theme (The Final Word) is revealed through plot, dialogue and visual elements.  

Structure                                                                   10 Points Possible

Effective use of three-act, odyssey, linear or non-linear story structure is demonstrated.  The layout is professional using industry standard spec screenplay formatting, with proper spelling, punctuation and grammar usage.

Narrative Voice and Content                                   10 Points Possible

The overall quality of the writing is strong and the tone is appropriate to the material.  The story is original and compelling and evokes emotion.  The narrative is distinct, cinematic, and effectively conveys the mood or “feel” of the movie.  The description of the setting invokes an identifiable sense of place and the descriptions are vivid.  The action, sequence of events, conflicts, and turning points propel the story forward.  The timing of the action, unfolding of plot elements and character development supports the plot. 

Characters                                                                10 Points Possible

The characters are well developed in the narrative and are unique, Interesting, compelling, and multi-layered.  The speakers are readily Identifiable, fully revealed and depicted with active goals.

Dialogue                                                                    10 Points Possible

The dialogue is natural, succinct, and unique to each character and the point of view is effective and consistent.  Any shifts in point of view are clear and intentional.  Use of language effectively reveals character, moves the story forward and mined for maximum expression.

POETRY

Use of the Theme                                                      10 Points Possible

Originality and creativity in interpretation and incorporation of the theme is demonstrated.

Emotional Impact                                                      10 Points Possible

The poem evokes emotion and allows for suspension of disbelief.

Message                                                                     10 Points Possible

The poem’s message is unique, fresh, and moving.

Form and Flow                                                           10 Points Possible

The poem is structured in a powerful way on the page.

Use of Language                                                        10 Points Possible

The language employed is mined for maximum expression, word choices are creative and effective, figurative language (metaphor, simile etc.) are fresh and unique.